	Archive \| PDF Mobile
	Today's paper. Last Updated: 06/01/2012	My profile: Login or register for free

Land Sale by Defense Ministry Brings Court Case

29 May 2012

By Rachel Nielsen

Sergei Nikolayev / Vedomosti

The Samara branch of the Federal Property Management Agency has filed a lawsuit against the Defense Ministry, alleging that the ministry auctioned off property for a price 2.2 times lower than its appraised value. Above, the Defense Ministry building in Moscow.

A firm with ties to the Defense Ministry has landed in hot water over the sale of real estate in a prime neighborhood in the southern city of Samara, with a federal agency saying the price tag was far too low, Kommersant reported.
Following the auction of about 5,200 square meters of land and buildings, the Samara branch of the Federal Property Management Agency filed a lawsuit in the region’s arbitration court seeking to have the auction declared null and void, Kommersant said Friday in its Volga edition.
A factory owned by the Defense Ministry, the Samara Clothing Equipment Repair Facility, filed bankruptcy in February 2011.
In March, the facility’s assets — the real estate — were sold at auction for 34.6 million rubles ($1.1 million) to a Samara-based company, Prombezopasnost.
The Samara branch of the federal agency said in court papers that “at a minimum, the price was 2.2 times lower than the price determined in an appraisal of the price made in accordance with the procedure in federal law.”
In spring 2011, the branch received a broker’s appraisal estimating the factory’s real estate assets at 76.6 million rubles. In its court documents, it said “the auction was conducted without the report of the government agencies having authority over the matter.”
The man who ran the facility’s bankruptcy proceedings said the same assets were sold at auction for about 6.5 million rubles in fall 2010, Kommersant reported. He said he already has been investigated by the police, the prosecutor’s office and the Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography because of the scandal.
Prombezopasnost didn’t comment to Kommersant about the possibility that the auction would be annulled.
Yelena Stryukova, a senior consultant for regional projects with real-estate firm Cushman & Wakefield, told The Moscow Times that property in Samara can cost from $200 to $450 per square meter, depending on its location and use. That suggests a range of $1 million to $2.3 million for a 5,200-square-meter property.

			This article has no comments. Be the first to leave a comment

Discussion

The Moscow Times welcomes your comments and invites you to discuss topics with other readers. Your comment will be posted automatically to enable a live discussion. If you aren't familiar with our comments policy, you can read it here.

If you're a registered user, you can start typing your comment below. If not, take a moment to sign up. and then return to the article.

If your comment doesn't appear, contact us by using our web form.

Comments

To post comments you must be registered

Comments via Facebook

Also in Business

BP Announces Intention to Sell Stake in TNK-BP British oil giant BP announced Friday that it intends to sell its 50 percent stake in the TNK-BP joint venture, signaling an end to the stormy partnership.	European Debt Crisis Driving Workers East Despite its inconveniences, Moscow has become a magnet for foreign job-seekers, as unemployment in Europe is hitting record highs amid the debt crisis.
Ruble Plummets Further Against Dollar The ruble continued its nose dive against the dollar Friday, plummeting by around 80 kopecks to a level of 33.73 rubles to the dollar by noon, after hitting a three-year low Thursday.	Q&A: The Glass Is Always Half Full for Citi Chief Turek It took a three-year stint in Africa for Zdenek Turek, the Czech-born head of Citi in Russia, to see his glass as half full.
Fridman Wants Big Change at TNK-BP TNK-BP co-owner Mikhail Fridman said BP's Soviet-born partners are urging the British company to return to talks about changing the proportion of the 50-50 partnership.	Foreign Staff for Sochi Olympics Foreigners would be able to work at the Sochi 2014 Winter Olympics under a special amendment to employment law currently being considered in the State Duma.

Comments

This article has no comments.
Be the first to leave a comment

Share & save

Also in Business

Penbro estate expected to sell for $3.5m

Philip Hopkins

April 9, 2012

INVESTORS will need more than $3.5 million to buy the signature Penbro property in the Glenburn-Yea Valley district. The property in the Yea River Valley, within one hour and fifteen minutes from the city, will be auctioned by Pat Rice & Hawkins on May 25 at 2pm at the Glenburn Hall. It comprises 568 hectares, located at the junction of the Melba Highway and the Murrindindi Road, only 84 kilometres from the city. The property is being sold by businessman Neville Bertalli, who has owned it for 30 years. It was once owned and run as a stud cattle property by formula one driver Alan Jones.
In Bentleigh a handsome double-storey period building is tipped to fetch at least $2.25 million when it goes under the hammer later this month. Teska Carson will auction the property at 438 Centre Road on April 27 at 2pm. The 340 sq m building is being sold with vacant possession on behalf of the mortgagee in possession.
Knight Frank's Leigh Morris and Chris Tsolis and CBRE's Mark Wizel and Scott Orchard are jointly marketing a development site in Keilor. Located at 31-37 Keilor Road, the property is being offered for sale by expressions of interest closing on April 27, at 3pm. The site has an approved permit for a 7-storey and a 4-storey building consisting of ground floor retail and 106 apartments. The project, ''Ess Garden Apartments'', has been designed by prominent architects Rothelowman.
In Clayton, a new, self-contained and fully fitted-out office suite in the Monash Corporate Centre at 750 Blackburn Road will be auctioned by Crabtrees Real Estate on May 10 on site at noon. The office suite has a building area of 139 sq m and holds a Business 3 zoning. It was previously leased at an annual rental of $34,000, and is expected to sell in the mid-$300,000 range.
A significant property investment with strong cash flow and the security of a Commonwealth government tenant is available in Dandenong. Gross Waddell is selling 53-55 Robinson Street - the Family Law Courts - with the price range expected to be $6.5 million to $7.0 million. The Family Law Courts has occupied the premises since 1984 and a new five-year lease has just been signed on April 1. The annual rental is about $608,567.
In Footscray, a realisation auction of 48 Eleanor Street, occupied by Ambulance Victoria, will be held on April 20 at 1pm. The agent is Sutherland Farrelly. The 700 sq m property that is developed with a weatherboard building is situated directly opposite the Western Hospital.
Sutherland Farrelly is also helping to sell "Murray Park Farm", a rural holding of 83.99 hectares at Barooga with frontage to the Murray River. It will be sold by receivers' tender closing April 18 at 3pm, by Sutherland Farrelly in conjunction with Andrew Jenkins Real Estate (5871 1025). The property, at 153 Seppelts Road, has water entitlements of 480 megalitres. It's expected to sell for at least $11.5 million.
At Victoria Gardens in Richmond, Teska Carson will auction a property at 137 Kent Street on April 27 at noon. It comprises a single-storey building on land of about 207 sq m zoned Business 1. The property is leased on a monthly tenancy at $2500 per calendar month. The agents expect offers of more than $750,000.